I argue for a referential view of definite descriptions. D3 the individual x that actually satisfies a definite description the f does not enter. The present chapter is an attempt to provide a critical assessment of segerbergs program. Existence and uniqueness are understood as a presupposition of a sentence containing a definite description. Consider now statements of the forms, respectively, t exists and a does. At the syntactic level, they contribute a free variable that. The referential theory of meaning and its problems. Download bookshelf software to your desktop so you can view your ebooks. Of definite descriptions received 5 august, 1991 1. Deep learning subsumes algorithms that automatically learn compositional representations. University of calgary bertrand russells theory of definite. This question calls for an ambitious empirical research program, but we can.
Pdf russells theory of definite descriptions researchgate. Definite descriptions paperback paul elbourne oxford. Bertrand russell ranks as one of the giants of 20th century philosophy. Reference and definite descriptions two uses of descriptions donnellan argues that neither russell nor strawson is right. At the same time the software costs are becoming more dominant in the total system costs. From basic payroll processing to integrated solutions incorporating payroll processing, human. Russell analyses definite descriptions similarly to indefinite descriptions, except that the individual is now uniquely. This however, was not the case in the late eighties and is definitely not the case today in the nineties. On the fregean analysis, definite descriptions are construed as referring expressions rather than quantificational expressions. Thus tweaked, russells analysis is that the semantics of a definite description in. In this paper russell took himself to be inaugurating a program of analysis. A number of authors have observed that the traditional russellian analysis of definite descriptions gets us into trouble when we embed descriptions into certain environments like propositional attitudes, conditionals, and questions see heim 1991 elbourne 2005, 2010, 20, forthcoming, neale 2005, rothschild 2007, hawthorne and manley 2012 and schoubye 2011, 20.
In this paper we examine the role of software engineering practice as an agent of changeimpact for societal sustainability through the manifestation of value sensitive concerns. This series is a basic introduction to russells theory of descriptions. Take as an example of a definite description the sentence. This claim is a separate thesis from the one which says that definite descriptions. Bertrand russells theory of definite descriptions sparked an ongoing debate concerning the proper logical and linguistic analysis of definite descriptions. Take as an instance the father of charles ii was executed.
Russell 1905 proposed to treat sentences containing definite descriptions e. Russells theory is an application of the attributive use of definite description in speech acts, whilst strawsons argument against russell is on the basis of him not recognising the referential role of definite descriptions. While it is now widely acknowledged that, like the indexical expressions i, here, and now, definite descriptions. What russell does propose is that apparent names singular terms, such as tony, are in fact truncated or telescoped descriptions. And, in spite of their opposition, they share some false assumptions in common. Take as an example of a definite description the sentence the current emperor of kentucky is gray. The ability of these models to generalize well has ushered in tremendous advances in many fields. Does strawsons critique of the theory of definite descriptions. On the role of value sensitive concerns in software. Til is an expressive logic apt for analysis of questions and presuppositions, because within til we work with partial functions, in particular, with propositions with truthvalue gaps. In this clear and carefully structured introduction to the subject gary kemp explains the following key topics.
Conditionals as definite descriptions a referential analysis. But now consider this sentence with the description unpacked. The types now match, and the sentence can be assigned a semantic value. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Russells theory of descriptions bibliography philpapers. The fregean analysis of definite descriptions, implicit in the work of frege and later defended by strawson among others, represents the primary alternative to the russellian theory. What does meaning mean in whitehead and russells pm. Plural functional terms, obtained by means of the descriptive apparatus, denote so called multivalued functions to be added to the usual functions, now.
Why was russells theory of descriptions taken seriously. Software analysis tools can provide this data at every stage of the cycle. R a selfguided tour to help you find and analyze data using stata, r, excel and spss. Russells theory of descriptions university of notre dame. A number of authors have observed that the traditional russellian analysis of definite descriptions gets us into trouble when we embed descriptions into certain environments like propositional attitudes, conditionals, and questions see heim 1991 elbourne 2005, 2010, 20, forthcoming, neale 2005, rothschild. Is the analysis that generates objective descriptions or. It is mostly linked to the dirty, bearded men that sailed the seven seas and robed merchant ships or ships that carried a valuable cargo. Introduction it is moderately paradoxical that the title of this address is an unfulfilled improper definite description because russell really had two versions of the theory of definite descriptions. In other words, and in contrast to his earlier russell 1903, russell proposed to treat definite descriptions, semantically, as a univocal class of nonreferring terms. Buy the cambridge companion to bertrand russell cambridge companions to philosophy by griffin, nicholas isbn. Payright workforce solutions offers tailored hcm solutions for businesses of all sizes. In this video, we begin by considering some puzzles about singular terms. Econ 201 chapter 1 key terms social science flashcards. According to the view that i advocate, definite descriptions are variables.
In this paper we examine the role of software engineering. Considering these aspects some of the most important considerations in the development and maintenance of computer software in costeffective reliable software. Such descriptions are commonly used in formal mathematical reasoning, as in a. In defense of russell according to bertrand russell 1905, 1919, definite descriptions phrases of the form the f and indefinite descriptions phrases of. In particular, he argues that russells analysis offers the basis for a coher.
And an apparent obstacle to neales program to extend russellian analyses of descrip. When you give yourself over to apple, microsoft, et. Questioni di semantica formale e logica plurale padua. In order to extend the category of terms to the plural case, autors propose a theory of definite descriptions that contrasts with the russellian one. He says it remains to interpret phrases containing the. Definitions and descriptions of analysis the older a word, the deeper it reaches. This book argues that definite descriptions the table, the king of france refer to individuals, as gottlob frege claimed. John smiths what is this thing called philosophy of. This apparently simple conclusion flies in the face of philosophical orthodoxy, which incorporates bertrand russells theory that definite descriptions. Each is partly right, because each focuses on just one of two different uses of definite descriptions. The cambridge companion to bertrand russell cambridge. Through his books, journalism, correspondence and political activity he exerted a profound influence on modern thought.
This supplement collects together various definitions and descriptions of analysis. Since there is no king of france now, it seems that the definite description. Arguments against the russellian theory of definite descriptions based on cases that involve failures of uniqueness are a recurrent theme in the relevant literature. Russells theory of descriptions only pertains to the so and sotype phrases. Philosophy of language russells theory of descriptions britannica. Classical russellian accounts predict them to be plain false, whereas presuppositional accounts predict them to suffer from presupposition failure, which leads to infelicity. Since such descriptions are necessarily ambiguous, they do not describe any definite object and as such cannot be assigned meaning in isolation e. Now that we have defined indefinite descriptions and definite descriptions, we can. Costeffective reliable software engineering and development. About us we are an innovative canadian manufacturer of power conversion products we designed our first switchmode dcdc voltage converter in 1976 and today we design and build. They argue that for the russellian account to be acceptable, it is not enough that all sentences containing singular definite descriptions have russellian truthconditions.
Russell analyses definite descriptions similarly to indefinite descriptions, except that the individual is now uniquely specified. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. One central debate in the analysis of definite descriptions concerns the truthvalue of sentences where there is no entity that meets the description in the definite. Whether or not you are a proponent of the russellian theory of definite descriptions. The f is f as semantically equivalent to there is one and only one f, and it is g. Denise retzlaff graduate program administrator for their generous assistance. This might in turn be used to explain the fact that every driver cannot bind a. Russells theory of descriptions 1 some puzzles youtube. Logic systematizes and analyzes steps in reasoning. Russells theory of definite descriptions is primarily concerned with denoting phrases e. The role of software systems on societal sustainability has generally not been the subject of substantive research activity.
1119 390 1217 109 910 1156 122 851 1601 248 1531 1103 796 1292 89 739 890 930 1290 1590 280 341 1190 31 1349 1063 187 341 1490 1221 1145 363 1336 1603 646 821 1129 575 506 1494 1262 1442 35 1490 1178 25 127 1454 188